Three new year resolutions to address poor boardroom behaviour, including yours

Did poor boardroom behaviour adversely affect the quality of key decisions taken by your executive and/or main board in 2023?

If so, what behaviour and by whom impacted what decisions? How might these decisions adversely impact the sustainable development of your organisation?

To what extent are you aware, based on feedback, of the extent to which your behaviour contributed to the problems? If you have not sought feedback on your behaviour, why not? Are you afraid? Do you care?

Examples of poor boardroom behaviour include:

⁃ bullying

⁃ talking over

⁃ not consulting everyone

⁃ not voting on key issues

⁃ silo behaviour

⁃ avoiding decisions

⁃ not tracking decisions

Can you list the key decisions taken by your main and executive board last year? Can you link those decisions to a shared purpose, a shared strategy and a shared behaviour plan? If not, these three resolutions may help you and your board in 2024:

Resolution 1: Seek to agree a shared sustainable organisation purpose (P) strategy (S) and behaviour (B) with your colleagues. Your decisions will carry potential risks without a shared Organisation PSB. I find that board members are far more divided on their purpose than they admit.

Resolution 2: Seek to clarify and find the courage to share your personal purpose, strategy, and behaviour plan (Personal PSB) with your colleagues. Risk making yourself vulnerable in this task. This will feel counter intuitive but it will pay off if confronted authentically.

Resolution 3: Seek to understand the PSB of your colleagues on your board and their feelings about yours. I find in my facilitation work with boards that if board members deepen their understanding of each other – including of personal histories, hopes and fears – then their decision-making behaviour improves, with significant positive impact on outcomes and a more peaceful – even joyful – time at work. Life’s too short for anything else.

Carpe diem.

Happy New Year.

Ciarán.

Most Mondays: how to find peace – even joy – at work. #1 Is it possible?

Most Mondays: how to hack work for peace – even joy – most of the time from your first job until your last, is the title of my next book, a series of blogs and a podcast. 

By most of the time I mean about 75% of the time. For most people that’s as good as it gets. But so many people don’t like Mondays and for whom Sunday angst is a weekly nightmare.

I know this because I’ve experienced that angst and I know it’s true for some of my clients who lead lives of quiet desperation and, if they don’t, their score is nowhere near 75%. 

I believe it’s possible to find peace – even joy – at work most of the time by taking control, responsibility, and by knowing how to meet your needs productively in your relationships at work. 

Peace – even joy – at work might seem a laughable concept. These are not words associated with work. We expect our work to be hard because we feel we must make so many compromises. Some of these are unnecessary.

Your starting point for peace – even joy – is your purpose in life. Your why. Get that right and you have the foundations of a fulfilling career.

So what is your life about? What is your purpose? I had to face this, in extremis, last year during chemotherapy for lymphoma. But don’t wait for your back to be against the wall like I did before you confront your purpose before you die, because you will die.

Your purpose can be expressed in one sentence. Your purpose is about why you do what you do. 

Is your purpose to make money, to make a difference, be the best at what you do or all three? Or something else? 

Or are you unclear, drifting or just getting by. Don’t worry, the process of finding a purpose is a purpose.

My next few posts will be about how to find your purpose.

#MostMondays

Ciarán 

Why boards find ESG and sustainability a bit of a turn-off and what to do about it…

“ESG and sustainability are at the top of my to-do list” are not words I usually hear from my executive and main board clients. Not that they don’t care or don’t understand the issues. They do. It’s just that they’re not top of mind.

I have identified seven points of inflexion which cause stress on the relationships between members of main and executive boards, which can negatively impact decision-making and, therefore, outcomes: new leadership, behaviour matters arising following a board review, rapid growth – especially following funding rounds, change in ownership structure, silo behaviour, and crises.

Pressure to reflect ESG and sustainability developments in decision-making is deemed essential but is down their list of immediate behaviour change items. The language of ESG and sustainability is distancing. Its use needs to deliver an immediate payoff in boardroom relationships. It doesn’t. It’s not user-friendly language. What can boards, GCs and chief sustainability officers do about this impasse? I propose a counter-intuitive remedy: more intimacy – an odd word I know – amongst those involved. 

I’m currently facilitating an executive board through a period of significant change. I have completed several cycles of one-to-ones with the board members, followed by plenary sessions. I’m now doing follow-up work with the chief executive, helping them ensure the progress made during those cycles endures. I’m pleased that the chief executive and the board members are happy with my work. They feel they have changed as a group – how they relate with each other, their main board, and other stakeholders. 

I’m relieved because it’s my first piece of board work since my remission from lymphoma and a year out for chemotherapy and a stem cell transplant. My confidence was low. This success was a personal boost. In addition, my experiences over a year in and out of hospital have changed my values entirely and how I approach my work. I now focus much more than before on facilitating a more profound understanding by board members of each other’s purpose, feelings and personal history as a foundation for behaviour change. It works and worked for them.  

Historian, philosopher, and the bestselling author of Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind Yuval Noah Hariri says: “In order to flourish, we still need to ground ourselves in intimate communities”. He’s right. And boards are potentially deeply intimate communities, not that intimacy and community are words that leap to mind in the context of boardroom behaviour. But that doesn’t mean every board meeting needs to be like a scene from Succession nor that fierce cut and thrust be the common denominator of boardroom behaviour. Indeed, the incentives for board members to deepen their understanding and knowledge of their colleagues are manifold. 

The incentive for your board to create a sustainable organisation by taking care of the environment and protecting society through good governance (ESG) should be strong. What’s not to like about the word sustainable? Surely, board members care about their decisions’ impact on their children and future generations? In theory, yes. But apart from having to respond to the growing body of ESG regulations, appointing chief sustainability officers – the fastest growing title at work – and thrusting the ESG mandate into the laps of in-house lawyers, boards appear to want to be like St. Augustine – good, but not yet. 

When I facilitated an interactive session with over 100 Chief Sustainability Officers at the Cambridge Institute for Sustainability Leadership (CISL) earlier this year, their need was clear: a roadmap to influence their boards. When I speak with GCs whose boards and bosses land them with the ESG “mandate”, I find they struggle to engage their board members on the issues.

What if GCs, chief sustainability officers and boards got into the same room to talk, not primarily about ESG and sustainability but their hopes and fears for their jobs, families and lives? About their purpose and how that links with the purpose of the organisation? Surely, these purposes are interdependent?

At a personal level, who but the most narcissistic board member – and I acknowledge they exist – would put their hand up to say that they don’t care about creating a sustainable organisation, about having a healthy environment and a safe society for themselves and future generations and that the route to that is better decision-making, i.e. governance? 

If the route to dignity, fulfilment and – even – joy at work for those in the boardroom were to be a declaration of their hopes and fears for themselves and their loved ones, might not ESG and sustainability take care of themselves?

I have launched a programme to facilitate those conversations. Please email me if you want to know more. 

Ciarán 

cfenton@ciaranfenton.com

Why boards should be concerned about the Solicitors Regulation Authority’s Review of In-House Solicitors

If your organisation employs in-house solicitors your board should be concerned about the Solicitors Regulation Authority’s recently published Thematic Review of In-House Solicitors.

If you are a chair, non-executive director, chief executive or member of a board or executive committee of an organisation which employs in-house lawyers and if you care about your organisation’s ability to sustain over the medium term and if you care about your organisation’s obligations to the environment, society and good governance then you should be concerned about the conduct of The Solicitors Regulation Authority. If you care about the wellbeing of your in-house lawyers you will be shocked by the Review.

Even if you think ESG is a fad, there’s no such thing as society and lawyers are overpaid deal-blocking necessary evils you should still worry about the conduct of the SRA because you should be concerned about the unintended consequences of its complacency in its regulation of the lawyers upon which you depend.

Conduct is defined as behaviour over time. The SRA’s conduct in respect of supporting and regulating in-house lawyers has been poor at best and reckless at worst. I have observed the problems at close quarters as a leadership consultant for many years, have written and spoken about the issues and wrote to the SRA several years ago to beg them to undertake an urgent thematic risk review. They refused.

Leading academics, notably Professors Richard Moorhead and Stephen Mayson, have written extensively about the issues for many many years but nothing has happened. Paul Gilbert, Chief Executive of LBC WiseCounsel, a consultancy which supports in-house lawyers, has worked tirelessly on the issues in his programmes, particularly on stress, and little has changed at a systemic level.

But it now looks as if the SRA has gone too far and in-house lawyers have decided, enough is enough. Your board should clock this milestone. I know in-housers well. They don’t like, as one said to me, “going tall poppy”. Well listen up because a bunch of them have created an oasis of outraged clamour in a desert of, what one described to me as, “omertaesque silence”.

According to a post on LinkedIn written by Jenifer Swallow, an experienced general counsel, in reaction to the Review a “number of leaders in the in-house community…are extremely concerned by the findings of the Solicitors Regulation Authority In-house Solicitors Thematic Review…are troubled by the fact that the SRA…does not appear to see the extent of the challenges for in-house solicitors that the Review signals – describing the findings as ‘encouraging’…that the Review understates the severity of the risks present in the in-house environment and misinterprets or is inadequate in its conclusions as to their cause…For example, independence is at the very heart of the tension in the client-employer relationship in-house and yet 64% of in-house solicitors are not raising their regulatory duties including the duty of independence with their client-employers. One in ten experience pressure to compromise their regulatory obligations. 50% of General Counsel feel isolated. Many in-house solicitors are overwhelmed and have inadequate board support. This should be a real cause for concern.”

They share a document (link below) setting out their concerns, along with practical steps and support they would like the SRA to provide. They go on to say that the “Review represents a significant opportunity to give the in-house legal environment the attention it needs and deserves. With high profile cases such as the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry under review and other corporate failings in the limelight, downplaying concerns delays this opportunity at a time when public trust in lawyers is both needed and in question. It also undermines confidence within the in-house community in their regulator and robs them of the support they need. The aim of our recommendations is to increase regulatory support for General Counsel and in-house lawyers in the service of society, without the only choice being to resign or conform in conflict with professional and regulatory obligations.”

What should members of your board and executive committee do now?

– ignore this milestone moment at your organisation’s peril

– read the Review and the GC‘s Response, then call the SRA and back them

– encourage your in-house lawyers to communicate the importance of their independence at every opportunity

You will be pleased that you did. Sorry if you don’t.

This story is not going away any time soon.

Ciarán

I know a few people starting new roles soon. Here are 7 First 100 Day Steps from my new book (in draft)…

I’m writing a book to be published by Globe Law & Business in October 2023. It’s aimed at in-house lawyers but the principles in book can apply to anyone. I know a few in-house lawyers starting new roles soon. Here is my current draft on my first hundred days section. I hope they, and others, find it useful to them.

Your first hundred days

Your first hundred days in a new role are special because – obviously, but not always remembered – you can’t have a second first hundred days in the same role. These are unique days. They start with hopes and fears. You hope that all will be well and so do they. By they, I mean the people who hired you. They will be as nervous as you might be. You will fear that you’ve made a mistake and so will they. But the bigger burden is on you. The view formed of you by others, the quality of those early relationships formed and your reputation generally will, by the end of the hundred days, be difficult to change by you. You will make irrevocable first impressions in your first key email, meeting, follow-up actions and especially in your first decision. The good news is that you will have a clean sheet to write a new chapter in your career, in your life and in theirs.

You will have a fresh opportunity to present whatever face you choose. You can decide what of your previous behaviour you will continue. What you will stop and what new behaviour you will try to adopt. Spend time reviewing the highlights and low lights of your previous role. What went well and why? What, if you had the time back again, would you do differently. It reminds me of the time when I changed schools when I was fifteen. I had been very unhappy in the previous school. I was young and socially immature and had contributed, I’m sure, to some of my own unhappiness. But in the main I had no guidance day-to-day in a boarding school in which thuggery and kindness were present in equal measure. The new school was bigger and a better environment for me but the key change f– I would like to feel, or have I imagined this? – was to start afresh as I meant to continue.

Remember that they – the jury – will stay out for variable lengths of time. I have facilitated scores of First 100 Days Programmes, and I have found that, on average, you will probably encounter your first Amber or Red relationship in your Relationship Grid (see Fig…) by Day 15. Although, on one occasion, a client who had just started a new role as COO encountered a Red by Day 5 because a decision, which was taken before he arrived, caused a risk event in his first week and was now his problem.

He called me and told me what had happened. I asked him what his problem was, especially since no one was holding him responsible for the event. He said his problem was that since he didn’t know his colleagues or the politics of the relationships between his colleagues on their ExCo he felt stuck as to how best to proceed: who to trust and to whom he should give a wide berth? I advised him to ask his CEO to advise him how to proceed and with whom. But could he trust his CEO? Well, if he couldn’t it seemed to me, he shouldn’t have taken the job in the first place.   

So be prepared to encounter a troublesome relationship from, as my North American clients say, the “get-go”. When the jury comes in you’re stuck with their decision. It will be hard if not impossible to lodge an appeal. So, make the best of this so-called honeymoon period. Here are seven steps to reduce risks and maximise your opportunities in your first hundred days:

First 100 Days – 7 Steps

  1. Be crystal clear on your personal purpose in life and at work before Day 1. If you’re not, you will be in trouble before you start and you won’t know why.
  2. Listen 70% of the time. Ask lots of open biased questions: Who? What? When? Where? How?  By biased I mean biased towards surfacing information that will help you populate your Relationship Grid (see Fig…)
  3. Demonstrate through your actions – don’t assert – how your personal purpose links to the purpose of the legal function and to the purpose of the organisation, assuming the latter is clear which it often isn’t. Do your best. The interdependence of these purposes will make or break your first hundred days.
  4. Communicate clearly what you intend to deliver in your first hundred days. Under-promise and over-deliver.
  5. Take this unique opportunity to make small changes in your behaviour based on your review of your last role. Imagine as I did, you are young and in a new school. Recall how much you would have wished not to repeat the errors you made previously.
  6. Never send a material email or text before you speak to the recipient. You’re not Tolstoy. Your former colleagues might have come to tolerate your telegraphic/florid/bland writing style over the years. Your new colleagues won’t.
  7. In your first Amber or Red encounter (see Relationship Grid Fig…) work through your feelings, your needs in relation to those feelings, and your options on how to handle the Amber or Red relationship. Deal with this first encounter poorly at peril to your first hundred days. See FEEL/NEED/DO on page…

They will judge you more on how you dealt with your first problematic relationship than on what you delivered during them. You will receive some leeway on delivery but your character will be judged on how others felt when you interacted with them. You will judge them similarly.

In extremis, you can decide to leave at the end of your first hundred days without too much damage. We all make mistakes. Better to take that tough decision then when the market will understand. Otherwise, and ideally, you should stay at least two years in a role or risk losing credibility in the job market.

An even tougher decision is for them is to accept that they made a mistake in hiring you and ask you to leave before the end of your first hundred days. This is rare. I find that more hiring mistakes are made by hirers than by applicants.

How many people in your organisation do you feel were poor hires by you? Why? Your answer will be as much a statement about you as about them.

Ciarán

Go for a change programme, not a review, this year…

I find that leaders, when addressing problems on their boards, executive committees or senior leadership teams, tend to cleave to effectiveness reviews, formal or informal, rather than cracking on with change programmes. 

Apart from companies required to carry out and publish board effectiveness reviews, I don’t see the value added in a two step approach i.e. a review followed by action on matters arising. 

Frequently, leaders santistise the written review findings for political reasons; they don’t address the matters arising, or if they do, they fail to change anything. 

My approach is to fix, not point by cracking on with a small change programme  with immediate impact. 

By small change I mean facilitating each board or team member to make one small change in their behaviour which, in aggregate across the board, will have a big impact on outcomes. 

I operate a three-step process as follows:

  • 1-1 meetings with each member of the board or team 
  • facilitated plenary sessions to explore issues arising in the 1-1s 
  • follow up 1–1s and plenary sessions during the Term of the programme – as many required to address issues as they arise as well as mediation sessions between pairs of members if required

Typical issues include:

  • not working together as a unit
  • one member causing most conflict
  • supine NEDs
  • chair interfering in day-to-day matters
  • poor governance and decision-making
  • unresolved conflicts
  • stress of rapid growth or scaling

Approach

  • clarity on organisational purpose, strategy and behaviour
  • clarity on individual member purpose, strategy and behaviour
  • reframed relationship agreements between members based on an understanding of how organisational outcomes depend on the behaviour of each member

Typical term

  • six to nine months

Best wishes,

Ciarán

Back to work after the holidays and chemotherapy. Now what?

I felt excited commuting downstairs to work this morning. Great to feel normal again. We’ve had a wonderful holiday catching up with people. They were all so kind during my year-long chemotherapy treatment. I’m in remission due to medical miracles and the kindness of stranger clinicians and nurses, now a big part of my life.

And, like the many cancer patients before me, I am not the person I was before my treatment. I must confront this first working day of the new year as a different sole employee of my consultancy to what I was a year ago.

What do I care about at work now? What’s my career purpose? What’s my answer to that question that I have so easily posed to hundreds of clients over 20 years? It doesn’t feel so easy now that the boot is on my foot. What’s my strategy? What’s my plan to implement that strategy? What’s my PSB?

Feck! I’m not sure. That’s why I’m writing this blog today. I must figure it out before tomorrow when people are back at work. After a year of ticking over, I must restart marketing and selling my services to them. I must play revenue catch-up. But what if…?

Doubts gnaw at my previous certainties. Can I sell board effectiveness programmes now with a straight face? Can I help senior leaders make career choices to find jobs to make a significant difference to the organisations they join? Do I care anymore whether my lawyer leader clients are sleep-walking into last chance saloon in their pact with society?

More broadly, do I care as much about politics, news and current affairs as I did? Why am I listening only to the news headlines and quickly switching to Radio 3 or sports? Time was I used the sports section of the newspapers to light the fire. Now I read it cover to cover. By the way, ’tis the best of journalism. Who knew?

My intention at work must, as I tell my clients, be about how my work contributes to my life’s purpose. But what’s that now? Nietzche’s famous observation was that if you can figure out your why, you can bear any how. This insight helped me through my bleakest days in the hospital. I did figure out my why: caring for those I care about.

So what has changed? I always cared about people, but they were not, in truth, always my primary focus in my all too busy life. Now I think about others first more than I did. Indeed, when I feel low, I pick up the phone to help others in more pain than I am. Why is that? Is it because I have needed them more, and it’s all about me, not them? Is it, as per my Dad’s favourite quote: there’s no such thing as an atheist in a foxhole? Will I return to my old ways when the fear of cancer eases?

I don’t think so. A good and kind friend, who has stood by me through the worst days, told me I found a richer version of myself through my experiences last year. I like this because it feels true. And because that’s what people frequently do in adversity.

But if I were my customer, I would now ask how this navel-gazing would put bread on the table, top up my pension and make me feel fulfilled as a fulfilled thing. What am I saying now to my customers? What does it mean for boards, teams and senior leaders teams needing support in difficult times?

It’s all very well for me to have fancy epiphanies, but in 2023, boards, teams and leaders face complex organisational choices, personal pain and challenges to their feelings of fulfilment. In-house lawyers, a market segment of niche interest to me, return to work at a time of uncertainty regarding their role and purpose.

Today, if you are a board, team or senior leader at a point of inflexion – scaling, leadership issues/changes, or career crossroads – I can help you if I can care about you. If I can’t, I won’t. Only hire me if you want me to care about you as much as your organisation. If I do that, your organisation will benefit. Organisations are a coalition of people’s career businesses for a relatively brief period. If I can help each person thrive I can help your organisation thrive.

How will I do that? What’s my strategy? It’s by helping people reframe their relationship with themselves, their boards/teams, their organisations and, ultimately, with society.

If I work with a board or team, I start working on the personal purpose of each member in one-to-one sessions; then, I work with the entire board or team in plenary sessions teasing out the interdependence between individual intent and organisational purpose. Then I facilitate a statement of shared purpose, strategy and behaviour. I can trace most organisational problems and conflict back to a failure to work through the pain of agreeing on a shared purpose, strategy and behaviour plan.

When I work with individual leaders on their career crossroads, I work through with them what I have worked through here for myself in this blog. I help them reframe their why, how and their behaviour plan – their PSB. Then I help them execute it.

When I work with in-house lawyers, I focus on helping them reframe their relationships with themselves, their profession, and their employer clients at a time of emphasis on the environment, society and governance. That’s the subject a book I’m writing for publishers Globe Law and Business to be published later this year.

I’ve come to the conclusion that everyone is connected in their involvement in the fulfilment business: how we fill our lives with meaning. We still must make money. I must. But it’s a means to an end. Not an end in itself.

All’s changed, as Yeats said, in a different context. For me, 2023 is about helping people reframe their relationships and they mine.

Ciarán

Please don’t tell anyone I’m following the footie…

Cancer changes everything. Whoever said that, ‘tis true, at least in my case. Everything has changed for me. My values, habits, and interests.

What and who I care about, and how deeply, has changed fundamentally. I have also become tidier after a lifetime of mess. And, mirabile dictu, I have started following the footie and worse, cricket. But you can’t tell anyone.

In male company particularly, there is no one more reviled than a wannabe Johnny come lately sports fan. Unless you can remember being lifted over the styles at six months by your Dad, can riff misty eyed on Nobby Stiles and ‘66 and pronounce Richarlison properly, best shut up in the pub. As for cricket, just don’t even try.

Not that I had zero interest previously. Many of my friends and clients are football and/or cricket nuts. Most like rugby. They frequently and generously invited me to games. One in particular invites me regularly to The Emirates and to Lords. He’s followed Arsenal, man and boy. Cricket is part of who he is. So I got the gist, enjoyed the games but didn’t care deeply. That’s all changed.

Since March I’ve had five long stays in hospital. The last, for my stem cell transplant, was for four and a half weeks. In isolation, no visitors. Did my feckin’ head in. Especially at the weekends. Hospitals change at weekends. The atmosphere morphs. It’s quieter. Staffing levels are different. Saturday mornings are the worst.

The weekend looms. How am I going to get through this? A kind nurse gets me a cappuccino and the Saturday broadsheets in the hospital shop. I used to read the news, politics and business pages front to back. Never but never ever read the sports pages front to back. Then one, weekend I figured something out.

All these years I’ve been furrowing my brow for too long over matters over which I’ve had no control, controlled often by lunatics and or charlatans, and invariably deeply depressing. Meanwhile my mates were also having great fun watching sport and reading the sports pages. Why not me? So, I gave it a go. No one needs to know.

First up I tried the T20 World Cup. It wasn’t on the hospital TV system so I listened to it on BBC Radio 5 Extra. I started to listen only to the news headlines on Radio 4, and instead of continuing to listen to some bullying cabinet minister with zero interest in governance bang on and on, I switched to Radio 5X, for the sport. I found myself caring. Excited. Don’t tell anyone.

The commentary was soothing. Ireland was playing. Did well out of a DLS (sic) call. I’ve always maintained that cricket is a crude derivation of Gaelic hurling. This doesn’t go down well with my cricket mates. Anyway, a friend said I should watch the last two overs of India v Pakistan on You Tube. I did. Kohli was mesmerising. Exciting. Fun. I told one of the nurses of my new nascent interest. She, from India, was reared on cricket. She recommended I watch or listen to as many whole games as I can and it will slowly become clear. I am and it is.

And so to football. On Sundays in hospital I watched Match of the Day before Kuensberg on Sunday. Not just the last ten minutes but the whole programme. I became interested in the managers. Fascinated by their contrasting approaches. I read about them in the sports pages. Then I watched the games more closely and became interested in individual players. I’ve watched many of the World Cup 2022 games. I even know some of the players names. I look forward to the games. But don’t tell anyone.

As for rugby, I’ve always liked it. Even played it at school. That said, we were forced to play all games at boarding school in Ireland. A different game each day: Gaelic football, hurling, rugby, and soccer (English football) by rotation. Amach air an bpáirc! They would shout in Irish. Get out on the feckin’ pitch now, in English. Hail, rain or snow. I was big, strong and tall, although devoid of skill. Useful, occasionally, in line outs. Otherwise hopeless. I was geeky, wore glasses and was called four eyes. V original.

I was invariably last pick for soccer (football) teams, but often on the best team. So I passed many a winter’s afternoon freezing cold in goal seeing little action, it being at the other end. Day dreaming. Then the ball would come my way. Sheer panic. But at least I was able to stop a ball better than I was at kicking and controlling it.

In the light of that history recent changes in my interests are taking me, pleasantly, by surprise. And, speaking of Richarlison, I might, when my hair returns, even consider a bleached hair and tatts vibe. Why not? But don’t tell anyone.

Ciarán

Three incentives for boards & teams to reframe their relationships, regularly

I find, time and time again, working with members of boards and teams that they miss out on opportunities and increase their risks by ignoring the constant link over time between the quality of their relationships and personal/organisational outcomes.

They miss out on opportunities because the poorer the quality of their relationships the more likely they will not attract the discretionary effort, innovation and candour from others essential for success at that level. “I would have suggested X but the CFO would have made a snarky comment about ROI, so I didn’t”. The idea never sees the light of day. They avoid the words “what if?” as too risky.

They unconsciously increase risks because members feel unsafe to speak out on potential risks. Why take the personal risk? “Everyone in the room knows what’s going on but said nothing. It’s a joke” Except it isn’t a joke.

Members frame their relationships to accommodate the lowest common denominator of behaviour. They view meetings as unavoidably political, low in trust, high in point scoring.

Issues they should raise with all team members they explore in the bar with just a few. They recall with anger and passion personal sleights, real and imagined. “Did you see how X looked at me when I gave my report? Did you?”.

Their decision-making processes lack rigour, consistency and challenge. Good governance goes by the way side. “We’re all agreed then” the CEO says. It’s a statement, not a question. Chilling.

The underlying problem is a belief that this conduct is just part and parcel of business life. It’s the way it is. No point in trying to change it since people are people and they won’t change. Or can they?

What if it were possible to incentivise members of a board or team to reframe their relationships regularly if they could believe that it would make a significant difference to their desired personal and organisational outcomes?

The first incentive to reframe relationships regularly is that desired personal outcomes are dependent to varying degrees on the desired personal outcomes of others. This is the case even in organisations wholly owned by one person. Elon Musk may now own Twitter outright but he needs other individuals with personal needs to make it work. Why not accept this reality since not to do so creates personal risk?

The second incentive is that personal and organisational outcomes are interdependent. This is separate from the dependency above. Your organisation is a coalition of individuals with their relationships, for a brief period. Your organisation needs you to help meet its needs. Equally you need it to meet your needs. Why ignore this interdependence?

The third incentive to reframe relationships regularly is that needs change over time. If needs change then relationships must change. Why ignore this imperative if in so doing personal and organisational risks increase and opportunities are missed?

If this sounds like hard work it’s because it is. But it’s no harder than the stress, frustration and potential failure in the status quo.

I will explain in future blogs how I facilitate reframing relationships and how you can too.

Ciarán

Your neutrophils are back, he said…

Your neutrophils are back, my Haematologist said to me the day before yesterday. Not just back, he said, but they’ve gone from zero to point three. His eyes twinkled above his mask. He was clearly pleased. I think I’m in love with my Haematologist. There’s probably a law against that. He’s amazing. Calm, caring and honest. I know a bit about leadership. He’s a natural. I’m lucky to have him. You can leave this room soon and get home next week, he continued. A tear escaped from one of my eyes. I had been having a bad morning mentally and physically. Under stress I tend to obsess about everything. I’m intellectually aware that that is an anxiety transfer mechanism. Emotionally in those moments I feel totally fecked. So that neutrophil news was tailor made for me in that moment. I had been in isolation for three and a half weeks, had six days of high intensity chemotherapy followed by a stem cell transplant followed by a tough week of side effects. All of which I was told had gone well – I was lucky not to experience serious nausea – and my recovery was ahead of average. I felt grateful for that but low and so the news that my neutrophils were back made my mood soar. Yesterday they leapt again and I was allowed out of the room for the first time. I liked that. I did several laps of the ward wearing my Panama hat, as my hair is all gone, and trying to cut a dash in my blue Gant work-shirt and jeans. Not sure I quite pulled a dash off but the nursing staff were very encouraging. Today I feel emotional. It’s as if, with the end in sight, I’m allowing myself to let go. I’ve been holding myself together for several weeks in this the seventh of seven phases. Hard to believe. Also hard to believe that this time last year I didn’t know the word neutrophil, or platelets or PICC/Hick line, or temperature spike or the myriad terms which have become all so familiar. The names of the drugs. The names of the daily routines. OK if I do your wee Obs? Ciarán the nurses say umpteen times a day as they check my temperature, blood pressure and oxygen flow. Has anyone ever said No? I joke. They come in at 2am to check my temperature and then at 6am to take bloods. I’m so used to it now. The day has a rhythm. The doors swish open and shut all day. Nurses doing wee Obs. putting up blood transfusion bags which I get regularly, bringing drugs, food, changing bed linen, and above all the 10pm tea, hot toast and butter which makes my day. That’s a big change from when lunch at The Bleeding Heart in London made my day. And I have come to know these nurses well. I’ve been in and out of hospital for long stretches since March and these nurses have become an integral part of my life. They are truly front line. They are kind, compassionate, and helpful. They work hard. I have taken time to get to know them, remember their names (at least try) and hear their stories of their lives. I advise anyone about to go through what I’ve gone through to invest time in getting to know the staff; listen to them; respect them; do what they ask. When I can I cancel the buzzer for them, make it easy for them to do Obs. to clean my room. Small stuff but it matters. Also I advise that you adopt an Adult-Adult relationship with doctors and nurses. It’s easy to become institutionalised and to adopt a Child-Parent relationship. There’s no doubt, as neurosurgeon Henry Marsh author of And Finally amongst others found that he felt he had lost power when he became a patient. I’m no neurosurgeon but I’m acutely aware of the power differential between me in bed and the doctor standing next to it. That’s why, when I can, I dress in work shirt and jeans and sit out looking much as I do at home. It was noticed by the staff. Not alone did it make me feel better but it made their jobs easier. They are trying to get through their day too. A positive attitude lifts everyone. I also tell them what I’m feeling emotionally not just physically. I’ve yet to be disappointed by taking this risk. It’s an Adult-Adult approach. Above all I have learned that figuring out my why, just as Nietzsche said, makes it easier to get through any how. It’s true. My why is about the people I love. That’s it. Nothing, but nothing else matters. I wish I had figured that out a long time ago. I’ve been loved and supported by so many people this year. I couldn’t have got through it without them. I’m so grateful. Those videos got me through. I learned to tell people honestly what was going on for me. I also learned to pick up the phone to those going through tough times. Next I have learned (had to learn) acceptance. I accept my cancer. I accept the wait until next week. I accept the painful side effects. I accept the toxic chemicals into my body. Initially I was terrified. Now I say bring ‘em on. This isn’t easy for me. Acceptance isn’t easy but there’s no other way. And I’m lucky. Many have had to accept much worse than I. Next I’ve learned to live in the moment as much as I can. The Power of Now as Eckhardt Tolle writes is all we need. There is no past, no future, only now. I’ve learned to turn towards pain, counterintuitively. By going deeper into pain we can transform it. I’ve experienced that. Finally, I’ve come to understand what kindness means. It about first being kind to yourself and then to others. My Haematologist – with whom I’m in love, did I say that already? – says I’m hard on myself. ‘Tis true but ‘tis changing because cancer changes everything.

Ciarán